So, drink isn’t after all going to kill you after all

Chris Losh

Chris Losh

24 March 2017

In fact, quite the opposite. It’s going to help you live longer.

The latest report from the British Medical Journal (BMJ) was full of long medical words but its gist was simple: moderate alcohol consumption is good for your heart.

This, of course, is nothing new. Studies have been throwing up conclusions like this for the best part of 50 years – it’s just that assorted health groups have tended to ignore them because the don’t fit with their 'all alcohol is bad alcohol' mantra.

The key word in the BMJ’s findings is the word 'moderate'. Drinking per se is neither good nor bad – it’s the way in which people drink that is important.

A couple of years ago we ran a fascinating article by Erik Skovenborg, a Danish doctor who is a member of Alcohol In Moderation.

Binge drinking, in other words, is the problem, not drinking.

Among much high quality research, he made the point that there is far less alcohol-related harm in the Czech Republic than Russia, despite the fact that the former’s men drank twice as much alcohol per head as Russians.

The reason? Czechs tend to drink regularly but moderately, whereas the Russians drink rarely but heavily. Binge drinking, in other words, is the problem, not drinking.

I’ve seen some fascinating graphs showing the impact of alcohol on heart disease – long before this BMJ report was published. Essentially, it’s a J-curve. If you drink no alcohol, you are more at risk than if you drink 2-4 units regularly. Six units is about the same risk as none, and above that there are clear health negatives.

As the BMJ report rightly concludes, 'it’s a more nuanced message'. Sadly, the one thing we know government (and the press) don’t have much time for in this area is complexity. They want simple messages, big headlines and, ideally, pictures of comatose 18 year olds on the streets of Liverpool.

This report is hugely welcome. A well-thought-out, balanced piece of research that acts as a much-needed counterpoint

They ignore the 'respectable drunks', happily tippling away on a couple of gins and half a bottle of wine every night, causing no trouble to the forces of law and order, but storing up no end of medical trouble for themselves down the line.

And before we get too smug, ask yourself whether you’ve tried recording your own alcohol consumption over a 12 month period? I have, and it’s scary.

This report is hugely welcome. A well-thought-out, balanced piece of research that acts as a much-needed counterpoint to some of the (clearly political) 'studies' that get funded by the anti-alcohol groups, who, it seems, will only be happy once we have introduced Prohibition.

What the report isn’t, however, is a piss-head’s charter, and if we take it as such we totally miss the point. The key is the word 'moderate'.

Remember that the next time you’re doing lay-backs or opening that third bottle of Burgundy.

Related content

News |  Imbibe Live

Imbibe Live: What’s going on after the show?

Imbibe Live knows that on Monday and Tuesday night after a long day of tasting, learning, networking and more, you’ll all be turning in early ready fo

News |  Wine

Wine isn’t holding its own in tough restaurant trading conditions

It’s hardly news that the restaurant industry is ailing, but it’s wine in particular that’s struggling for attention, according to Wine Intelligence’s

News |  Wine

After the storm: Brunello

Forty years ago, it was the poorest hill town in Tuscany, Now montalcino is a wine world aristocrat.

News |  Beer & Cider

Malt in beer: The most important ingredient of all

In a beer world of ever more esoteric added flavours, it’s easy to forget the key role played by the most important ingredient of all: malted barley.